158
Nintendo Wipes Out 400+ Switch Emulator Repos in Single-Day GitHub Sweep * TorrentFreak
(torrentfreak.com)
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
I didn’t think emulators were copyright infringement since they’re built from scratch. Why isn’t GitHub telling them to get fucked?
They don't wanna be sued. Emulators are technically legal but Nintendo likes to abuse every loophole in the book to argue otherwise.
Nintendo eternally sucks but the Yuzu team handed their asses to the lawyers on a silver platter. Taking donations is one thing but a paywall to play the latest big first-party games is legal bait.
Emulators have been a coding exercise that came with a nice side benefit. Devs were deliberate about separately the work from piracy. Then a group like Tropical Haze makes money on writing an emulator and release a 0-day update that runs Tears of the Kingdom.
Emulation isn't a place for entrepreneurs.
I don't think taking money for making an emulator is the problem per se, and it's unlikely it had anything to do with why Nintendo took action against them. It's... everything else you mention. The brazen, unquestionable, open piracy, and the publicity of being able to play a game that hadn't even been released as you say. And the DMCA in the US makes switch emulation itself a more viable legal target, because in this form it circumvents Nintendo's encryption like the article you link points out. You can sell an NES emulator, no problem.
If anyone can afford the lawyers and has an incentive to challenge Nintendo, surely it’s Microsoft…..
I think they don't really care actually. Sure, they could afford to defend the people who voluntarily spent 100+ hours to build a repository using their tools but what's in it for them?
They don't have much money, as they need to pump every cent into their aiOS
What's their incentive?
A little good press for GitHub to offset all the bad press from downtime.
This is good press for GitHub. Corporations are their customers, not us. They want to show how friendly and easy to work with they are to corporations.
Doesn't seem worth the time or effort to lawyer up over.
I don't see an incentive for them here.